18 November 2026
Doing Well by Doing Good, TDM's response to Milburn, written by TDM's MD & Director of Studies
Written by Derrin

A TDM "from the front lines" response to the Milburn Review.
The Development Manager (TDM) have been starting new apprenticeship jobs for people for nearly 20 years, mainly helping people aged under 25 to win their first career break in cutting edge Digital Industries. Our vision is that those young people should Do Well by doing Good. Once they are employed, TDM partner with our employer partner to stretch and challenge them as they develop business skills and human and professional skills as well as technical skills. Only by developing this range of skills do employees become employable.
How does TDM respond to Milburn's 267-page review?
This is merely a report. Policy decisions, which will give us more practical clarity, will follow via a Parliamentary process across a 10 year period. So we won't assert any confident conclusions here, and will instead respond to the spirit of the thing.
For an employer considering apprenticeships, the central message from Alan Milburn is that Government should make employing and training young people cheaper and less risky, whilst employers must create substantially more first-job and apprenticeship opportunities. The report title is clear: "From a Welfare State to a Working State: a new settlement for the next generation", and chapter one states:
“This Report sets out a new ambition for the country: a generational promise that every young person will be guaranteed the opportunity to earn or learn.”
And the report describes its plan as:
“a plan to make youth participation a new core priority for the country.”
The UK is not going to compete on a global stage if we underfund adult employee skills development in response to the government's own "The UK's Modern Industrial Strategy 2025". So, leaving aside (for this blog post at least) Milburn's completely batty notion that it is smart in the age of AI and digital transformation to withdraw full funding for adult apprentices and degree apprentices aged over 25...
At TDM, we enthusiastically support the "D-Day" spirit being energised by Milburn. High youth unemployment is a very expensive way of creating social and economic crisis, and it is the opposite of our own Vision Statement, that all people can and should do well by doing good. We think employer organisations share an intergenerational responsibility for bringing the next generation into productive work. As AI and other digital tools emerge at an exponential rate, bringing new people, younger or older, into employment on one of our apprenticeship journeys is not just a matter of fairness. It is also a matter of improving business efficiencies via digital and AI transformation projects, underpinned by strong systems, data, cyber and improved marketing.
bringing new people into employment on one of our apprenticeship journeys is not just a matter of fairness, it is also a matter of improving business efficiencies
Employers should ask: choice, impact or cost?
We would highlight three legitimate "But, what about...?" concerns for our employer partners:
- But, what about the choice?
- But, what about the impact?
- But, what about the cost?
But what about the choice?
TDM have been judged as strong on inclusion by Ofsted, and our completion and achievement rates are well above the national averages. We want to get disadvantaged young people onto apprenticeships: more than 65% of our learners have some form of disadvantage, and more than 45% come from disadvantaged postcodes. We achieve this through a very effortful recruitment filtering process that keeps our employer partners' own recruitment and embedding interests at its heart.
As Milburn initiates many new employment access support agencies, employers still need a supportive filtering process that weeds out people who don't "Get it, Want it, nor have the capacity to succeed" in that particular role or apprenticeship with that particular employer. The last thing TDM would wish to do is build up a young person's dreams only to smash those dreams down when the reality of work dawns. So employers will still need TDM's applicant filtering service, and we will remain frank with applicants about what is needed to land their new job. Employers don't employ someone as an act of generosity. They employ someone they expect to do good for their organisation, their clients and their stakeholders.
Employers just don't employ someone as an act of generosity
But what about the impact?
When the young person lands the role, that is where the real work begins. According to our Values, all human "Agent Boss" workers in the emergent AI era need to be Driven, Accountable, Productive, Vulnerable and Considerate. Failing to understand the business goals for the role, or the technical skills to fulfil it, or failing to deliver on those human and professional values will cause the new employee to fail.
Failing to understand business goals, technical skills or human and professional values will cause the new employee to fail
And none of us want that outcome for anyone.
But what about the cost?
There has to be some cost-benefit analysis. Some paltry financial incentives are being proposed, with restrictive conditions, for employers who commit to employing or apprenticing young adults. Young apprentices were already not expected to pay National Insurance, but the total investment cost of a new employee or apprentice remains high. Apprenticeship fees may be negligible, but the apprentice's wages and, more expensively, the cost of mentoring by your senior staff as they embed that apprentice all adds up.
So what offsets this? If a learning programme under-challenges the learner, for example with:
- too much classroom work
- not enough employer impact coaching
- too many easy challenges, for example low-brow business admin tasks
- not enough future thinking, for example nothing on data, AI or cyber skills
is that enough value for money?
if a learning programme under-challenges the learner, is that enough value for money?
Want to pick up this debate?
I am on LinkedIn if anyone wants to pick this debate up with me. And if you are an employer weighing up how to recruit or reskill the next generation through apprenticeships, our team would be glad to talk it through.



